Where Thoughtful Gifting Feels Like Home
Featured Products
Premium Pine | Raised Wood Lettering | Custom Finish
Make a statement at your front door with a handcrafted, double-sided porch sign designed to welcome guests in style.
Each sign is made from a 4 ft tall 1X8 premium pine and features raised 6mm basswood lettering for a beautiful dimensional look that stands out from traditional vinyl designs.
Fully customizable to fit your style:
Board Color
Lettering Color
Wording
Perfect for doorways, covered porches, realtor closing gifts, housewarmings, or everyday curb appeal.
🪵🎨Handcrafted Production Time:
Every porch leaner is made by hand from raw wood through the final protective finish. Each piece requires multiple layers of paint/stain and polyurethane with proper curing time, please allow 1-2 Weeks for completion.
Welcome guests in style with our handcrafted 16” round “Welcome to Our Home” door sign - designed to bring warmth, personality, and a custom touch to your entryway.
Each sign is beautifully finished in a rich Early American stain for a timeless farmhouse look, and features 3mm basswood raised lettering painted bold black for a clean, dimensional design that truly stands out. Each door round comes with your choice of personalized heart, paw print, football, baseball, basketball, or hockey puck.
✨Make it uniquely your: Choose from a personalized heart, paw print, football, or hockey puck design.
✨The standout feature: The “O” in HOME is a magnetic, interchangeable piece - allowing you to personalize your sign with a name (family, pet, team) or swap for seasons, holidays, or your favorite sport!
Each sign includes one starter interchangeable “O” of your choice, with the option to purchase additional designs to switch anytime.
Finished with a rustic burlap bow and greenery accent, this piece is ready to hang and make a statement on your front door or inside your home
Elevate any gathering with this stunning marble and acacia wood charcuterie board set. Designed for both beauty and function, this 11-piece collection makes the perfect closing gift, housewarming present, wedding gift, or holiday entertainer’s set.
The natural acacia wood paired with smooth white marble creates a timeless, modern look that fits any home style - from coastal to farmhouse to contemporary.
👉BUSINESS LOGO CUSTOMIZATION👈
Add your business logo for discreet engraving on the back for $10. If selected, please visit our Custom Design and Photo Upload Page after checkout and include your order number so we can match your artwork to your purchase.
Explore our full collection of personalized gifts
🎁🧺
Add a Gift Basket to Any Order for Just $10
Make your gift feel truly special!
Every order from Not Your Average Basket Case is thoughtfully packaged and ready for gifting. Items are placed in a gift box or gift bag with tissue paper and protective wrapping.
But if you want that extra “wow” moment…
Each gift basket is uniquely styled using hand-selected baskets, crates, or containers - beautifully wrapped in cellophane with a bow - making your gift just as “Not Your Average” as the items inside.
Meet the Founders
This business began in a new season of life for both of us. As longtime friends, mothers of grown daughters, and women grounded in faith and family, we found joy in creating meaningful gifts that make a house feel like home.
Through life's changes - loss, retirement, and grandchildren - we were inspired to build something rooted in love, creativity, and intention. Every piece we create reflects that journey.
We pride ourselves on offering a thoughtfully curated collection of handcrafted, personalized and custom gifts designed to elevate every occasion. Each item is carefully selected, crafted and customized, blending quality craftsmanship with timeless style to create gifts that are both beautiful, unique and meaningful.
Belinda & Gabrielle